Possessive and possessed cases: Difference between revisions
Larry Sanger (talk | contribs) Adding material from possesive case--needs to be integrated |
Larry Sanger (talk | contribs) m Adding material from possesive case--needs to be integrated |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
A case which exists in some languages used for possession. It is not the same as the [[genitive case]], though the two have proximal meanings in many languages. |
A case which exists in some languages used for possession. It is not the same as the [[genitive case]], though the two have proximal meanings in many languages. |
||
| ⚫ | |||
| ⚫ | |||
| ⚫ | Many languages make this distinction in some way. Saying something like 'I have my dad's big nose' with the latter noun-phrase marked inalienable would imply some sort of genetic inheritance; marked alienable, it would imply that you had cut off your father's nose or somesuch and were actually in physical possession of it. |
||
| ⚫ | |||
| ⚫ | |||
| ⚫ | Many languages make this distinction in some way. Saying something like 'I have my dad's big nose' with the latter noun-phrase marked inalienable would imply some sort of genetic inheritance; marked alienable, it would imply that you had cut off your father's nose or somesuch and were actually in physical possession of it. |
||
English does not have a grammatical facility to make such distinctions. |
English does not have a grammatical facility to make such distinctions. |
||
The term 'possessive case' is often used to refer to the "'s" [[morpheme]], which is suffixed onto many nouns in english to denote 'possession by'. This usage is not strictly correct -- this [[affix]] is actually a [[clitic]]. See the entry on the [[genitive case]] for details. |
The term 'possessive case' is often used to refer to the "'s" [[morpheme]], which is suffixed onto many nouns in english to denote 'possession by'. This usage is not strictly correct -- this [[affix]] is actually a [[clitic]]. See the entry on the [[genitive case]] for details. |
||
---- |
---- |
||
Revision as of 15:51, 25 February 2002
A case which exists in some languages used for possession. It is not the same as the genitive case, though the two have proximal meanings in many languages.
There are many types of possession, but a common distinction is alienable versus inalienable possesion. Alienability refers to the ability to disassociate something from its parent -- in this case, a quality from its owner.
When something is inalienably possessed, it is usually an attribute: for example, John's big nose is inalienably possessed, because it cannot (without surgery) be removed from John -- it's simply a quality he has. In contrast, 'my briefcase' is alienably possessed -- it can be seperated from me.
Many languages make this distinction in some way. Saying something like 'I have my dad's big nose' with the latter noun-phrase marked inalienable would imply some sort of genetic inheritance; marked alienable, it would imply that you had cut off your father's nose or somesuch and were actually in physical possession of it.
English does not have a grammatical facility to make such distinctions.
The term 'possessive case' is often used to refer to the "'s" morpheme, which is suffixed onto many nouns in english to denote 'possession by'. This usage is not strictly correct -- this affix is actually a clitic. See the entry on the genitive case for details.
The following is an article submitted under possesive case, and might contain material worth integrating with the above:
Possesive case is a case that exists in some languages used for possession. It is not the same as the genitive case, though the two have proximal meanings in many languages.
There are many types of possession, but a common distinction is alienable versus inalienable possesion. Alienability refers to the ability to disassociate something from its parent -- in this case, a quality from its owner.
When something is inalienably possessed, it is usually an attribute: for example, John's big nose is inalienably possessed, because it cannot (without surgery) be removed from John -- it's simply a quality he has. In contrast, 'my briefcase' is alienably possessed -- it can be seperated from me.
Many languages make this distinction in some way. Saying something like 'I have my dad's big nose' with the latter noun-phrase marked inalienable would imply some sort of genetic inheritance; marked alienable, it would imply that you had cut off your father's nose or somesuch and were actually in physical possession of it.
English does not have a grammatical facility to make such distinctions.
The term 'possessive case' is often used to refer to the "'s" morpheme, which is suffixed onto many nouns in english to denote 'possession by'. This usage is not strictly correct -- this affix is actually a clitic. See the entry on the genitive case for details.