User talk:Peaceray/Converting Havard citations to shortened footnotes (sfn)/Ecosexuality draft
Recreating the article
[edit]I believe that this article needs to be recreated, & I would like it to be a joint effort with people who are familiar with Ecosexuality. I am an experienced editor, aproaching 16,000 edits on English Wikipedia, which currently puts me in the top 5,000 English Wikipedia editors. Thus, I know enough about the process to help folks at an edit-a-thon.
Preparation
[edit]In preparation for the edit-a-thon, I recommend the following:
- Before the edit-a-thon, register & set your preferences:
- If you do not already have an account, please register for one at: Special:CreateAccount
- At Preferences-->Editing, uncheck Temporarily disable the visual editor while it is in beta & set Editing mode to Show me both editor tabs. This will allow you to edit either with VisualEditor or with Wiki markup.
- At Preferences-->Gadgets under Appearance, I recommend checking Add an [edit] link for the lead section of a page.
- Bring a computer!
Pertinent Wikipedia guidelines & policies, plus an essay
[edit]At your leisure please have a gander at the following Wikipedia guidelines & policies, in order of importance:
- Wikipedia:Core content policies (which explains the three of Wikipedia's Five pillars most pertinent to our edit-a-thon)
- The Content guide from Wikipedia:List of guidelines
- Wikipedia is not a soapbox or means of promotion
- Wikipedia:Copying text from other sources (in a nutshell: don't)
- Wikipedia:Close paraphrasing (in a nutshell: Summarize in your own words instead of closely paraphrasing.)
- The Wikipedia:Sexual content essay (in a nutshell: Wikipedia is not censored! (hooray!))
- If you have an Ecosexuality publication or sponsor an Ecosexuality event, please see Wikipedia:Conflict of interest
From two previous versions
[edit]- User:Peaceray/sandbox/Ecosexuality draft, which is nearly the last version before deletion, & from which we can grab Wikimarkup.
- The 2015-11-28 version of the article from Web Archive; sorry no Wiki markup from there ...
Why it was deleted
[edit]Unfortunately, I do not have the talk page discussions or edit summaries, but apparently there were complaints about the inclusion of copyrighted text, self-promotion, & conflicts of interest. However, the article was tagged with the following complaints:
- This article may be in need of reorganization to comply with Wikipedia's layout guidelines. (June 2015)
- This article may document a neologism in such a manner as to promote it. (August 2016)
- This article contains content that is written like an advertisement. (August 2016)
The deleting administrator posted a notice of speedy deletion, then ignored my contesting of that & deleted it anyway. When I asked for detail as to why, the admin cited the Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over essay, which represents an opinion, not a policy or guideline. Nevertheless, we are up against some attitude here.
What we need to do
[edit]- Write a lead section with the clearest definition & explanation of what Ecosexuality is.
- Find a non-copyrighted (public domain) version of the Ecosexuality manifesto, or be prepared to write the gist of it in our own words, without closely paraphrasing it
- Include at least ten secondary (preferable) or tertiary sources. Some can be found in the References section of the old version, but there are also many primary sources there that should be instead relegated to a Further reading or External links sections, as per guidelines.
- Bring your ideas, thoughts, & words! We need to make this more than just a stub article.
I look forward to editing with you! Peaceray (talk) 07:10, 30 December 2016 (UTC)
Possible sources
[edit]- Google Scholar search; note that more citations tend to denote a more respected source, although newer sources will obviously not be as well cited.
https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=ecosexual*&hl=en - Google News search; try to go with the reliable sources rather than the sensational ...
https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&tbm=nws&q=ecosexual*&oq=ecosexual* - Google book search; use the preview when available; if you have the book or can get it from the library, that's better
https://www.google.com/search?tbm=bks&q=ecosexual* - Worldcat search
http://www.worldcat.org/search?q=ecosexual*&qt=results_page - This video needs viewing; ecosexuality is covered, but the video may be more background than a source
Beth Stephens CDAR post-screening Q/A. archive.org. 2014-02-04. Retrieved 2016-12-31.Goodbye Gauley Mountain, Beth Stephens, ecosexual, Annie Sprinkle
Discussion & suggestions
[edit]Feel free to add any comments below. Prefix with an asterisk to add a bullet (two or more asterisks to indent a bullet) or prefix with one colon or more to indent (more asterisks or colons = more indented). Please sign your comments at the end with four tildes, like so: ~~~~