Awarding the album three and a half stars at New Release Today, Phronsie Howell describes, "This Changes Everything is a strong combination of vocals from powerhouse singers, creating inspirational music that is good for the soul."[2] Kelly Meade, rating the album three and a half stars for Today's Christian Entertainment, writes, "With the release of This Changes Everything, their harmonies blend together with Southern and traditional Gospel music creating a sound that’s all their own."[3] Giving the album four stars by The Christian Beat, Madeleine Dittmer states, "This Changes Everything truly gives glory to God in each song."[1]