Jump to content

User:Yuweij/Kunming Lake/BarrrrbY Peer Review

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

General info

[edit]
Whose work are you reviewing?

Yuweij

Link to draft you're reviewing
User:Yuweij/Kunming Lake
Link to the current version of the article (if it exists)
Kunming Lake

Evaluate the drafted changes

[edit]

Lead

[edit]
  • Has the Lead been updated to reflect the new content added by your peer? - The Lead stays original.
  • Does the Lead include an introductory sentence that concisely and clearly describes the article's topic? - Yes, it introdueces the location, landscape near by, and the size, which gives readers a brief introduction of Kunming Lake.
  • Does the Lead include a brief description of the article's major sections? - The Lead covers most of the sections, except the tourist attraction section.
  • Is the Lead concise or is it overly detailed? - No, the Lead is just right for readers to get a brief information of Kunming Lake.

Content

[edit]

Guiding questions:

  • Is the content added relevant to the topic? - Yes, the added content of water source and tourist attractions are relevant to the topic.
  • Is the content added up-to-date? - Yes, the content added are current information of Kunming Lake.
  • Is there content that is missing or content that does not belong? - All the content relates to the topic. But I think it would be better to add information about the number of tourists that travel to Kunming Lake each year in tourist attraction section.
  • Does the article deal with one of Wikipedia's equity gaps? Does it address topics related to historically underrepresented populations or topics? - The topic does not relate to underrepresented topics, so I think it should be fine.

Tone and Balance

[edit]

Guiding questions:

  • Is the content added neutral? - Yes, most of the content is neutral. But it would be better to delete the word "obvious" in "However, the water source was obviously insufficient in 1949", because "obvious" sounds a little subjective.
  • Are there any claims that appear heavily biased toward a particular position? - No, the claims are fair.
  • Are there viewpoints that are overrepresented, or underrepresented? - No.

Sources and References

[edit]

Guiding questions:

  • Is all new content backed up by a reliable secondary source of information? - The references about tourist attraction are from published book, which is reliable. However, the content in "water source" section have no reference yet, which should be added before publishing.
  • Does the content accurately reflect what the cited sources say? (You'll need to refer to the sources to check this.) - Yes, it is accurate.
  • Are the sources current? - Yes, the sources are published after 2000.
  • Are the sources written by a diverse spectrum of authors? Do they include historically marginalized individuals where possible? - There are two authors so far that talks about tourist attraction of Kunming Lake. I think it would be better to add more reference that address to this topic.
  • Check a few links. Do they work? - Since the references are books, I did not find a way to check the ebook through the link.

Organization

[edit]

Guiding questions:

  • Is the content added well-written - i.e. Is it concise, clear, and easy to read? - Yes, the language is fluent.
  • Does the content added have any grammatical or spelling errors? - The first sentences of Nanhu Island/Zhijing Pavilion Island/Zaojian Hall Island are not complete. It should be written as "XXX located on the east side of Kunming Lake".
  • Is the content added well-organized - i.e. broken down into sections that reflect the major points of the topic? - Yes, the content is organized logically.

Overall impressions

[edit]

Guiding questions:

  • Has the content added improved the overall quality of the article - i.e. Is the article more complete? - Yes, by introducing water source and tourist attraction, readers would have a better understanding about Kunming Lake.
  • What are the strengths of the content added? - It introduces the value of Kunming Lake as a tourist landscape.
  • How can the content added be improved? - If there are any shows or literature ever mentioned Kunming Lake, it would be great to add those information. Also, there should be reference for water source section.