Wikipedia:Peer review/Earthless discography/archive1
| Toolbox |
|---|
This peer review discussion has been closed.
This is an experimental page of sorts. I've never seen a page like this before and took the initiative of possibly introducing it. My first such page was Scale the Summit discography. It is my belief that these albums are notable but there's not enough to go around to fill-out a complete article on any of these individual subjects.
Yes, I am aware that From the Ages looks like it could be split-off into its own article, but try to remember, as its own article it would look underdone and appear to omit details (it doesn't, but without looking into the sources or trying to scare-up more one cannot be sure of this).
My overall take on the article is that it's pretty much done. Here are a few issues I know might exist with it:
- There's probably always some sort of improvement to be made to the lead paragraph.
- We no doubt need a photograph of the band in the same section.
- Sonic Prayer has received little attention in mainstream media; I have found a few, shall we say, alternative resources that I wish I could use but am unable to at this time.
- Rhythms from a Cosmic Sky is practically done, may just need a touch-up or two.
- Live at Roadburn has only what I would see at the moment to be an incomplete touring history following its release. I, however, cannot substantiate with sources anything that's missing. On that note, I have wanted to write in the touring history for both of the first two albums but have been unable to find anything. I absolutely would if I had anything, though.
- From the Ages is practically complete unless something new turns up.
As I would see it, that is all that needs to be fixed... but then again that's why I'm here: Can anyone else take a look at this and help me see what's missing? Could it possibly be ready to go for GA or FL status (I'm more certain it is a list and as such the next step would be the FL)?